The Easiest Way To Build A Commander Deck - Quick And Simple Method

Commander Guide 
Genoslugcs · December 31, 2022 · 4 min
The Easiest Way To Build A Commander Deck - Quick And Simple Method

Commander is Magic: The Gathering's most popular format. It also has some of the most complex deck building in the game. There are tons of different things that complicate Commander deck building - Decks are 100 cards, you can only have one copy of each card, you can only use colors in your Commander color identity, and much more.

You'll find a lot of resources online breaking down all the ends and outs of the process, in great detail. Today's article isn't one of them. The details are great, but today we are looking at the easiest way to build a Commander deck and we're keeping it simple.

I find that it's hard to know where to start when you consider a deck as a single 100-card entity. That said, this method breaks the process down into a few very manageable steps. I've used it to build decks from start to finish in 30 minutes or so. I should say now though - This method is fast and easy, but there's no way to get around playtesting and refining your list to get it optimized. In other words, don't expect the first draft to be a 10/10.


The Pile Method

There are six simple steps to this method. They are as follows:

 Pile 1: Commander And Lands


Start off by taking your commander and 35 lands and setting them to the side in a pile. The lands aren't significant at this point, so don't sweat exactly what lands you'll be running yet. For example, let's use Ardoz, Cobbler of Warimage as our commander. So, we would set him and for now, 35 basic Mountains, to the side.

You May Also Like: All New Commanders From Jumpstart 22

Pile 2: Core Strategy Cards


We'll now begin creating piles of 16 cards. Our first 16-card pile will contain cards that are at the core of your deck/commander's strategy. For our example, I would say this would mean cards with haste that could use Ardoz's ability. Don't worry about things like removal or mana rocks just yet, unless they happen to be on a card at the core of the strategy. Here are some examples:

Once you have 16 cards that work directly toward your strategy, set them aside.

Pile 3: Support - Card Draw & Mana Ramp


This pile will also be 16 cards and should contain cards that will help move the game plan laid out by the first pile along. It might look something like this:

Once your support cards are done, set them aside.

Pile 4: Interaction


This means single target removal, board wipes, counterspells, and graveyard hate - Anything that disrupts opposing gameplans or stops yours from being disrupted goes here.

You May Also Like8 MTG Cards To Buy Right Now At Low Prices

Pile 5: The "You" Pile


The last 16 cards can be whatever you like. I like to add cards here that didn't quite make it into the other piles. This is also the pile to add your favorite pet cards that you can't build a deck without. In other words, personalize your deck and/or fill in the gaps here. Here's what I would add to my hypothetical list:

Once this pile is complete, you'll be able to combine all your piles and have a 100-card Commander deck! However, before you shuffle everything together, there is one more step.

The Mana Base


As I mentioned above, we simply set 35 lands aside without worrying about what lands. Now is the time to tweak your mana base to accommodate the spells you added. The deck today is simple since it's only a single color. However, if you're in multiple colors, you'll want to take some time here and make sure you have enough lands for each color.

If you get here and you have a very high or very low mana curve, you will have to add or remove lands accordingly.

We set aside 35 basic lands at first... And you could certainly play the deck like that if you wanted. That said, here's an example of what I would add in place of a few Mountains.

The Numbers

You can now shuffle all of the piles together and you should have a fairly cohesive deck in about half an hour. Moving forward you may need to refine things if it doesn't play well. However, I've found that the more you use this method the better you get at assembling cohesive lists this way.

Here is a look at the numbers for a few key categories for the example deck today. Overall, I would say the numbers are about where they need to be even after one draft. Unless you have some specific reason for these numbers to be drastically off, you'll probably want them somewhere near here.

  • Mana Ramp - 15
  • Card Draw - 13
  • Single Target Removal Spells - 11
  • Board Wipes - 3
  • Lands - 35

 There are also a few game-winning combos that are worth mentioning, as it is always important to keep your win-cons in mind. The combos I included are:

See what others are playing in the current Commander meta here.


Some decks are always going to be harder to get optimized than others. And all decks are going to take some testing to get polished and playing at their best. That said, I have found that this method takes out a ton of the work and makes it very easy to know where to start. It really is the quickest, easiest, and simplest method to build a Commander deck that I have ever used. So, get out there and get to building that next list. When you do, comment and let me know how it goes for you.



Login to comment


Search Articles

Enter The Battlefield Prepared

With the MTGA Assistant deck tracker MTGA Assistant

Latest Articles

Corrupt your opponents with these delectable Early Access poison counter brews.

My five favorite ways to make money with Magic: The Gathering.

Giving a very quick rundown on the best picks in Limited for Phyrexia: All Will Be One.

The Early Access event for Phyrexia All Will Be One begins Thursday, February 2

A detailed look at Minor Misstep - Is it good or bad and when should play it? Let's find out.

Format defining commons? Nope. But they should find a home in many upcoming decks.

MTG Valentine's Day Gift Guide
Guide Information 

29 Jan by Genoslugcs

A guide to great Valentine's Day gifts for MTG players.

A deep dive on Friday Night Magic. How to prepare for your first FNM - Plus tips & tricks to do well

Last day of previews, most trending ONE cards, Affinity and Flashback now deciduous.

A look at what Ad Nauseam was pre-ban, losing Simian Spirit Guide, and what the deck is now. RIP SSG

Today we're taking an in-depth look at five decks built with Phyrexia: All Will Be One cards.