All of Maro's If/When Day Posts In One Location

Interview Wizards 
By: Kagros - 27 Apr 2020

Mark Rosewater just hosted another one of his If/When days on his blog. Members of the community can ask Maro how likely something is returning/coming to a Standard-legal Magic set (or, if specified, come to a supplemental Magic set) and he will give his opinion on how likely those things will get released. There are four different responeses he will give (from most to least likely): Big When, Little When, Little If, Big If. You can read his original post for more details on this here.

Below, I will list all of Maro's responses without any of his commentary. If you'd like to see his commentary, go check out his blog here

Update: If/When day is over! All responses are below

All If/When Responses

Raven Man getting card - Little When

Another Brushwagg - Little When

Seb McKinnon basic land cycle - Big When

Standard legal set with Slivers - Little When

Turtle Tribal - Little When

Returning to Multiple sets on one plane - Little When

Supplemental product aimed at Pauper - Big If

Cards with old border in supplemental products - Little When

Return to Alara - Little When

New race of animal people like Leonin and Rhox - Big When

Soldier tribal return - Big When

Actual Angel Planeswalkers - Little When

Magic Origins 2 with different set of Planeswalkers - Little When

Legendary Goat - Little When

Madness in Standard - Little if

Wedge set with factions centered on rightmost color in casting cost - Little When

Lightning Bolt in Standard - Little If

Morph/Manifest - Big When for Morph, Little When for Manifest

Cephalids - Little If

Another Plane with Gods / God Tribal - Big When

New White instant with CMC 3 or less that exiles target creature - Big When

Ravnica 4 - Big When

Multiplayer Draft focused set - Big When

More Generic Partners - Little If

Special Draft set like Conspiracy, but without Multiplayer gameplay - Little When

Modern Horizons 2 - Big When

Changelings - Big When

More Ultimatums - Little If

Return to Tarkir with wedges - Big When

Kylem as a standard set or any of the supplemental set planes - Little If

Elspeth's Home Plane in Standard - Little If

Angel Tribal - Big When

Winter/ice-themed plane - Big When

Red / part red Treefolk - Big If

Treefolk Planeswalker - Big If

More Planechase - Little When

Paper Supplemental Remastered Set (like Tempest Remastered) - Little If

Plane with natural gnomes - Little If

Yawgmoth as God of Phyrexia card (supplemental likely)- Little When

Garruk's homeplane in standard - Little If

New cards for Praetors - Big When

Another Unset - Big When

Double-faced creatures that transform into Planeswalkers - Big When

Strong 2-color theme non-Ravnica world - Big When

Enchantment tokens that have a large presence, like food in ELD - Little When

Planeswalker that cares about counters on things - Little If

Naga Planeswalker - Little If

Cards for other major Planeswalkers with 4 loyalty abilities - Big When

Benevolent, heroic shapeshifter Planeswalker or legendary creature - Big When for Legendary Creature, Little If for Planeswalker

New set on Shandalar - Little if in Standard

Splice on more than one or two cards in a set- Big If

Standard set with major enemy color pairs-matters that isn't a wedge set - Big When

Sapient, intelligent, speech-capable hydra and a set with a lot of hydras - Big if on sapient, speaking hydra, Little When on set

Enchantment Tokens - Little When

Poison counters in Standard - Big When for Poison's return

Single sided werewolves - Little When

Loxodon Planeswalker - Little If

Bird Tribal - Big When

Named Turtle character - Little When

Curse subtheme - Little If for large, Little When for small

Phyrexian Planeswalker - Big If

Great Designer Search 4 - Big When

Drake tribal - Little If

Cyberpunk Plane - Little If

Return to Amonkhet - Little When

New versions of remaining Weatherlight legends - Big When on major crew, Little When on more minor characters

Demon focused set - Little If

American-west themed world - Little When

Updating shortlist on Maro's FAQ - Little When

Ravnica product during Guildpact founding - Little If

Fiora in Standard - Little If

Nahiri as main character in a set - Little When

Takara, Starke's Daughter - Little When

Microbe themed world - Big If

Dwarf tribal - Big When

Non-Core set split between two planes - Little When

Supplemental crossover set (Like D&D the Gathering) - Little If

Mark Rosewater card like Richard Garfield PHD - Big If

Black border 5-color Planeswalker - Little When

Legendary Saproling - Big If

Squirrel Planeswalker - Little if in silver border, Big If in black border

Foxes - Little When

Glimpses on how Kamigawa has changed over the past 3000 years in a supplemental set - Little When

Abzan legendary squirrel in black border - Little If

Grandeur on new cards - Little If

Otaria set - Little When when playing a role in Dominaria return, Little if of being centered

Norse Mythology plane - Big When

Ashiok home plane set - Big If

Evil Gatewatch set - Little If

Nonlegendary creature that can be commander - Little if for legendary noncreature, Big If for non-legendary creature

Return to Lorwyn - Little If

Return to Kamigawa or Kamigawa-focused Commander product - Little If on former, Little When on latter

Standard non-Core set with a prominent Dragon theme - Big When on Dragon theme, Little When on prominent

New Garruk color - Little If

Reveal that two different planes are on same world - Little If

Three color commands - Little When

Design revolution on the same scale as double faced cards - Big When

Another set with a lot of Eldrazi - Little If

Creature type: Dinosaur Wizard - Big If in black border, Little If in silver border

Sorin and Nahiri in same set - Big When

Set with protagonist is one of the normal antagonists like Ob Nixilis - Little When

Spider as a focused tribe in a set - Little If

Planeswalker from Lorwyn/Shadowmoor even on a different plane - Little When

Creature that both adds mana and has ETB bounce "Man-o-War Elves" - Little If

Historic or another bunching keyword - Big When

Gingerbread widow planeswalker or legendary creature - Little When

Shard/arc set - Big When

Ante returning to Magic - Big If

A Asmoranomardicadaistinaculdacar,The Underworld Cook card - Big If

Magic's 6th color - Big If

Legendary Goat or legendary creature that cares about Goats - Little If

More Bear Tribal supports or Legendary Bear - Little When

Confirmation of Wanderer's identity - Little If

One of the major mono colored Gatewatch Planeswalkers gaining a second color - Little If

Skeleton tribal indepent of Zombie tribal - Big If

Return to Kaladesh - Little When

Blue/non-black Zombies - Big When

Ravnica set where a guild mechanic is a returning mechanic that didn't debut on Ravnica - Big When

Maro killing Magic - Big If

New Aminatou card - Little When

Vraska on a non-Ravnica plane - Big When

Replacement for prowess as Izzet keyword - Little When

Insects with tribal identity and support - Little When

Enchantress support outside of Bant colors - Big When on other colors having enchantments an enchantress deck might want, Little if on other colors having "when you cast an enchantment, draw a card"

Angrath - Little When

Calix and Estrid cards - Little When for more enchantment matters Planeswalkers

Return of Magic Invitational and card for winner - Little If on former, Big When on latter for winning events

Selesnian Planeswalker from guild - Little If

Black Bordered Planeswalker whose loyalty is counted by something other than loyalty counters - Big If

Davriel - Big When

Cards where artists that don't normally work on Magic are brought in for art - Big When

More Gatewatch - Big When

Standard set with main counter besides +1/+1 or -1/-1 - Little When

Hybrid mana cost Planeswalkers - Little When

Ravnica Planeswalker in non-guild colors - Big If

Video footage of Maro's toaster working - Big When

Ajani focused set - Big When

Visible physical disability Planeswalker - Little When

Liliana card with white mana symbol - Little If

New UU counterspell with upside - Big If

Planeswalker at non-Mythic rarity - Little When

Tocasia card for supplemental set - Little When

New card frame - Big When

Something like one of the Time Spiral sets - Little When

Legendary creature depicting Gix - Little When

Garruk-focused set - Big When

Ape tribal - Little When

New backside art for cards - Big If

Another set like Dominaria with fewer mechanics and lots of power/complexity at uncommon - Big When

Bog from accounting legendary creature or planeswalker in silver border - Big If

Seeing Gideon again - Big If

2 mana Planeswalker in Standard - Little If

More black bordered squirrels - Little When

Set Design led by Ari Nieh - Big When

Cards that let you expand your color identity in commander - Big If

Orggs on non-Dominaria planes - Little If

More Snow cards anywhere - Little When

Food (not the mechanic) based plane - Little If

Aetherborn Planeswalker - Little If

Richard Garfield on Design team - Little When

Death of Magic - Big If

More than a couple of one-of Kavus in a set - Little If

Return to Innistrad - Big When

Doubling Season reprint - Big When in supplemental, Big If in standard

Werewolves in a non-Innistrad set - Little When

Flushed out Vryn in a set - Little When

More Ugin - Big When

Ashnod card - Little When

Standard set that takes place a centry or more in the past or future relative to surrounding sets - Little When

More Atogs - Little If

Sword and Sorcery world - Big When

New card type - Little When

Return of Monarch - Little When

Legendary creature that cares about Energy - Little When

Magic set where story is focused on time travel - Little When

Quadcycle lands - Big If

Dice rolling in black border - Little If

Return to Tarkir - Little When

Updated Mechanical Color Pie article - Big When

Gorgon Tribal - Little If

Horror Tribal - Little When

Return to Lorwyn - Little If

Set based on five caster types (cleric, wizard, warlock, shaman, druid) - Little When

Companions in silver border - Little If

Standard Daretti - Little When

About Kagros:

Aether Hub News Team member. Writing thoughts on Magic news and fun gameplay!


Login to comment


Not sure, but MaRo said that it is a big when, also it is poison, not infect ;)
When is poison coming back?
Agreed, I'd really like to know the future of infect in standard but anything that can fuel my need for for poison/infect is something I'd enjoy
I wish the question asked about Infect specifically. Poison isn't really a problem; it's Infect. But if Wizards wants to print more Infect cards, I'm definitely down.
Poison counters in Standard - Big When for Poison's return

Search Articles

Enter The Battlefield Prepared

With AetherHub's MTG Arena Deck Tracker MTGA Assistant

Latest Articles

Let's go over the various sources of information about the meta and identify their pros and cons

Brief report on my 15 runs of Premier Draft for AFR. Also, giving away 1k gem codes.

Let's do a simple raffle for some 1k gem codes around the question: "Is the shuffler broken?"

2 years' worth of rank decay data indicates that the competitive player base is growing consistently

How to accumulate about 880k gold, 39k gems, and almost every card in standard after 29 months

The Strixhaven College Cup is upon us. Join the events and support Witherbloom College!

Conviene il bundle Historic Anthology IV? Analizziamolo insieme.

Yes, sometimes Jank can get there. All the way to Mythic. The puppers went the distance!

New Kaldheim decks
Metagame MTGA 

01 Feb by andreliverod

A sourced list of the top-performing decks from the Kaldheim Pre-release weekend.

Content creator Covertgoblue has made a bunch of brews to try out this Prerelease.

Quick Drafts
Guide MTGA Events 

23 Jan by andreliverod

In Quick Drafts, you do the draft portion of the event with AI bots.