Traditional Historic - Sultai Superfriends

20 15 28
9 13 12 27
Control

After netdecking for Historic for this past season, I finally decided to attempt to put something together on my own, pulling in from my favorite wedge Sultai.  Sultai has fantastic options for control, and some very high-end planeswalkers, which led me to attempt to build a functional superfriends deck here.  I tried to build a similar list in Standard, but losing Uro really hurt, and it ended up just being safer to play Dimir control there.  Hopefully Historic is a bit more forgiving when it comes to decklists (probably not though since from what I understand about 20% of the meta is Jund Sacrifice).  Anyway, on to the cards!

 

Creatures

Uro, Titan of Nature's Wrathimage - Super important to any list running Simic colors, Uro helps us keep pace with faster decks by bolstering our life total and letting us dig for answers (ramp as well which is always welcome).  Started at a full boat and cut to 3 to make a little bit of room for more interaction.

Hydroid Krasisimage - The flying squid is a great drop after you resolve a Nissa, Who Shakes the Worldimage, thanks to all the shocks we have in the list.  Draw+Lifegain+a big body is a fantastic deal in this deck, especially since there aren't a ton of ways to draw cards for the most part until you hit 5 or 6 mana.  Don't be afraid to drop this boy as a 2/2 in order to draw a card to keep up with your opponent.  2/2 flyers chump well, and can toss in chip damage after all.

Questing Beastimage - Probably the second best overall green creature currently seeing play, he serves multiple purposes, hitting planeswalkers on a normal attack as well as sticking around as a fantastic blocker.  Could probably use another copy here, and I'll update after doing some more testing.

Elder Gargarothimage - Hot take here, I think this is the best overall green creature currently seeing play.  He may not do anything upon entering play, but if he sticks, he will outright win games on his own.  Such a fantastic card.

 

Instants / Sorceries

Removal Suite

Assassin's Trophyimage - Needing BG to cast this keeps it from being truly broken, but hitting any permanent (lands included) makes this top tier, premium removal.  3-of due to the possible inability to cast it turn 2 thanks to the mana cost.

Maelstrom Pulseimage - Another great removal option in Golgari (they really seem to get the best removal spells in the game), these also serve to hit token decks and if you ever run into a Scute Swarmimage in Historic, you'll be praying for this off the top.  Being versatile enough to hit any permanent (barring lands) is also a nice bonus.  3rd copy in the board in case you need it in game 2.

Extinction Eventimage - The mainboard sweeper.  Not fantastic, but I prefer this mainboard to other cards like Bontu's Last Reckoningimage or Ritual of Sootimage thanks to it's easier to hit casting cost, along with possibly missing part of our board.  Only running 10 creatures means it really hurts to hit our own stuff, especially if we end up exiling them.  Other sweepers can come in as replacements out of the board if they have a more favorable matchup.

Casualties of Warimage - Kill all the things.  Game two you can kill all the things twice with a second copy out of the board.

Permission

Essence Scatterimage - Due to the lack of early creatures, I decided this was a better option than Negateimage mainboard, and the hard counter status it gives means it's relevant all game long, unlike Mystical Disputeimage for example.

Neutralizeimage - Probably our best option for hard counters thanks to it's cycling ability in case you stall out.

 

Planeswalkers

Narset, Parter of Veilsimage - She'll hit more often than not, and with all the high-powered walkers and removal spells, she more than holds her own.  Shutting down additional draws is nice, but more often than not, a non-factor.

Tamiyo, Collector of Talesimage - A single copy of Tami found a slot here, thanks to her ability to both feed Uro, and pull spells out of the bin for a second use as needed.  I don't think that utility justifies more than a 1-of however,

Nissa of Shadowed Boughsimage - Mostly inferior to Nissa, Who Shakes the Worldimage, she does bring a bit of extra utility by giving you some recursion along with buffing the creature she drops into play.  The fact that her lands don't stay creatures also keeps them safe from sorcery speed removal and sweepers which can be very good as well.

Ashiok, Nightmare Museimage - I'm always surprised at how well Ashiok controls the board.  His tokens are legitimate blockers and can be really annoying for the opponent to deal with since they'll either exile at least one card from your opponents library or eat a removal spell that would probably be better spent elsewhere.  2/3 is a viable body as well.

Nissa, Who Shakes the Worldimage - This card is still pretty much broken.  Doubling your mana off of forests, while dropping legitimate threatening board states from nowhere, she is a game ender if she sticks.

Liliana, Dreadhorde Generalimage - Biggest Lili is great.  She clogs the board, acts as removal, and her ult will cause almost every player to scoop as soon as she gets it off.  Drawing off of creature death is also extremely powerful.  She's really good guys.

Ugin, the Spirit Dragonimage - Still one of the best top ends in the game, even with the expanded card pool.  I don't think I need to say anything else since it's all been said already.

 

Mana Base

I went with lands that enter untapped here to help with our control suite as well as playing things on curve.  Triomes are great, but dropping one turn 4 or 5 and staring longingly at one of the 4 or 5 drops in the list feels really bad.  I'm sure it can use a bit more work here, but it currently seems to be pretty efficient.  25 feels a bit short at times, and I may make some adjustments in the future.

 

Conclusion

Superfriends as an archetype is one of my favorites, and while Grixis probably has better PW options, Sultai has the better control options (in my humble opinion), and the capacity to play cards like Uro.  This is still very much a rough draft, but I feel like it has the capacity to be a decent player in the Historic meta right now.  Let me know what you think and if you export it I hope it performs well for you!  Cheers!

 

Edit 1: -1 Elder Gargarothimage, -1 Liliana, Dreadhorde Generalimage, +1 Hinterland Harborimage, +1 Woodland Cemeteryimage.  Going to 27 lands and cutting 2 big drops to improve efficiency.  Thanks for the suggestion Patty!

 

Edit 2: Quick QOL update.  -1 Neutralizeimage, -1 Hinterland Harborimage, -1 Woodland Cemeteryimage, -1 Fabled Passageimage, +1 Essence Scatterimage, +3 Zagoth Triomeimage.  Trimming the Neutralize for more early game creature interaction since this list really has a tough matchup against aggro.  Triomes coming in to replace a lost cycle and fix a little bit more consistently.  We REALLY want to get to T4 or T5 with this list and I feel like this will get us there a little bit more often.

Comments

Login to comment

3 comments

TurtleBox
Really enjoying this list on the quick play ladder but haven't touched ranked with it.

I absolutely adore Tamiyo and seeing her get some love here warms up my heart.
SoliloquyNow
The Lil and Garg trims seem like a pretty solid place to start. I'll probably start there too. If you can, keep me updated! I'd love to hear from other players on how well this list is performing.
_Fereshkan
I agree with Sultai having better control options. I've been experimenting with wayyyyy to many variations of Grixis splashed green for ramp. I'm gonna take a breather from that and give this a shot. I love Elder Gargaroth. Big ole 5 mana do nothing if its answered, but I've seen far to much aggro in Bo3 currently so he will probably be okay mainboard. Definitely needs 1-2 more mana. I'll drop a Lil and Garg for 2 mana, and see how it goes. Flood sucks but Uro offsets it fairly well.GL my PWlkr
SoliloquyNow
Last Updated: 28 Oct 2020
Created: 24 Oct 2020
1075 279 3

Mainboard - 61 cards (28 distinct)

Creature (9)
$4.09€5.810.87
$4.39€4.290.55
$12.87€13.440.97
$1.10€1.460.06
Instant, Sorcery, Enchantment, Artifact (13)
$2.95€2.030.13
$0.80€0.850.45
$0.50€0.430.02
$1.38€1.110.02
$0.22€0.120.03
Land (27)
$16.48€15.350.17
$12.00€10.190.15
$13.86€13.390.29
$1.22€0.940.02
$1.61€1.170.02
$2.50€1.830.02
$5.71€4.120.15
$0.500.03
$1.000.03
$18.45€16.600.57
Planeswalker (12)
$0.95€0.670.04
$14.23€9.400.07
$3.37€2.290.02
$0.50€0.290.02
$17.94€20.460.03
$3.80€2.830.02
$2.22€1.680.03

Sideboard - 15 cards (9 distinct)

$0.40€0.270.02
$0.50€0.430.02
$0.25€0.100.04
$0.25€0.190.03
$1.38€1.110.02
$0.35€0.330.02

Add deck to your favorites

Please log in to be able to store your favorite decks for easy access under My Decks in the main menu.

Enter The Battlefield Prepared

With the MTGA Assistant deck tracker MTGA Assistant
Main/Sideboard Rarity Count
8 4 34 15 0
3 3 9 0 0